The Annual Ritual Nobody Asked For
You know the feeling. The calendar alert appears. “Annual Performance Review. Prepare Feedback.”
Your stomach drops. Your palms sweat. You suddenly remember you have a dentist appointment.
Similarly, on the other side of the table, your employee feels the same dread. They see the same calendar alert. They suddenly remember they have a dentist appointment too.
Funny how everyone’s teeth become urgent during feedback season.
The Giver’s Dilemma: Why We’d Rather Do Anything Else
Let us be honest. Giving feedback feels terrible.
Most managers would rather clean the office fridge. They would rather reorganize the supply closet. They would rather sit through a three-hour meeting about synergy.
Indeed, avoiding conflict comes naturally to us. Nobody wants to be the bad guy. Nobody wants to crush someone’s spirit before lunch.
Furthermore, we fear the backlash. What if they cry? Getting defensive is another concern. Worst of all, what if they secretly hate us forever?
Consequently, we soften the message. We wrap criticism in compliment sandwiches. We use vague language like “opportunity for growth.” We smile while delivering bad news.
But here is the truth: vague feedback helps nobody. It confuses the receiver. It frustrates the giver. And it wastes everyone’s time.
The Receiver’s Reality: Why We’d Rather Not Hear It
Now consider the other side. Receiving feedback feels equally terrible.
Nobody wakes up excited to hear about their flaws. We prefer to believe we’re doing fine. We prefer to think we’re the exception.
Nevertheless, the feedback comes. And it stings.
Suddenly, you’re defensive. Out pours the explanation for your actions. Then come the justifications for every decision. And before they’ve even finished, you’re already mentally preparing your rebuttal.
Similarly, you take it personally. They’re not criticizing your work; they’re criticizing you. Your identity feels threatened. Your competence feels questioned.
Consequently, you shut down. You nod along but hear nothing. You smile but feel furious inside.
The Compliment Sandwich: A Recipe for Confusion
Many managers use the “compliment sandwich.” You start positive, deliver criticism, and end positive.
This approach sounds good in theory.
In practice, however, it backfires spectacularly.
For instance, the receiver focuses on the criticism. They ignore the compliments entirely. Or worse, they suspect the compliments were fake.
Alternatively, they focus on the compliments. They completely miss the criticism. They walk out thinking they’re amazing.
Consequently, nobody wins. The message gets lost. The feedback achieves nothing.
The Disaster That Could Have Been Prevented
Let us paint a familiar picture. A project goes off the rails. A deadline gets missed. A client complains loudly.
Afterward, everyone asks the same question: “How did this happen?”
But here is the uncomfortable truth. Someone saw it coming. Weeks ago, someone noticed the warning signs. They noticed the errors, the delays, the miscommunications.
Yet they said nothing.
Giving feedback feels uncomfortable. After all, nobody wants to be the bearer of bad news. Furthermore, we convince ourselves it will get better on its own.
Spoiler alert: it never does.
Why Early Feedback Changes Everything
Imagine a different scenario. Someone speaks up early. They mention the small error before it becomes a catastrophe. They address the misunderstanding before it spirals out of control.
Consequently, everything changes.
The project stays on track. The client stays happy. The team stays sane.
Similarly, the receiver benefits. Correcting their course early becomes possible. Public failure and its humiliation? They avoid that entirely. And they learn without the scar tissue.
Moreover, the relationship strengthens. The giver shows they care. The receiver feels supported. Trust builds instead of erodes.
In short, early feedback prevents disaster. Time is no longer wasted. Money stops burning through the budget. And everyone’s dignity? Preserved.
Why We Wait Until It’s Too Late
Nevertheless, we still wait.
Why? Because fear wins.
We fear hurting feelings. Being wrong terrifies us. The awkward conversation makes us cringe. And being labeled “difficult”? That’s our worst nightmare.
Furthermore, we convince ourselves it’s not our problem. Someone else will handle it. Someone else will say something.
Meanwhile, the problem grows. Small errors become big problems. Minor misunderstandings become major conflicts.
Consequently, what could have been a five-minute conversation becomes a five-month disaster.
The Secret to Giving Feedback Before Disaster Strikes
Here is the secret. Make feedback a habit, not an event.
Do not wait for the annual review. Similarly, do not rely on the quarterly check-in. And above all, do not wait for the disaster.
Instead, give feedback regularly. Give it casually. Give it kindly.
For instance, say: “Hey, I noticed something. Can we chat for two minutes?”
Similarly, say: “I want to share a quick observation. No big deal, just thought you should know.”
This approach removes the drama. It removes the fear. It removes the sting.
Consequently, feedback becomes normal. It becomes routine. It becomes just another part of work.
Why Both Sides Need to Get Over Themselves
Nevertheless, feedback remains essential. You cannot improve without it. Teams cannot function without it. Companies cannot grow without it.
Therefore, both sides need to step up.
For the giver: stop softening.
Be direct but kind. Be specific but not cruel. Focus on behavior, not personality.
For instance, say: “Your report had three errors” instead of “You’re careless.”
Similarly, say: “I noticed you interrupted twice in the meeting” instead of “You’re rude.”
Likewise, say: “You missed the deadline by two days” instead of “You’re unreliable.”
And say: “Your presentation lacked data on the third slide” instead of “You’re unprepared.”
See the difference? The first version describes what happened. The second attacks who they are. One is fixable. The other is just insulting.
For the receiver: stop defending.
Listen first. Ask questions. Clarify before reacting.
Instead of explaining why you did it, ask: “Can you give me an example?”
Similarly, when you feel attacked, try asking: “What would look better?”
Rather than justifying your behavior, ask: “How did that impact you or the team?”
And finally, instead of getting defensive, simply say: “Thank you. Let me think about that.”
Yes, thanking them feels unnatural. It feels like surrender. But trust me, it disarms the situation. It makes you look mature. And it buys you time to process.
Consequently, the conversation becomes productive. Both sides feel heard. The feedback actually lands. And nobody leaves the room crying or plotting revenge.
How Life Would Be Better If We Spoke Up Sooner and Gave Our Feedback
Picture this world.
Managers speak up early. They address issues before they escalate. They guide their teams with confidence and care.
Employees listen openly. They correct course early. They grow without the trauma of public failure.
Projects run smoothly. Deadlines get met. Clients stay happy. People sleep better at night.
Furthermore, relationships flourish. Trust replaces suspicion. Collaboration replaces conflict. People actually enjoy working together.
And the best part? Nobody dreads the annual review. Because nothing said in that room comes as a surprise. Because everything was already addressed.
The Final Verdict: The Feedback
Let us face reality. Feedback will never be fun. Neither side will ever truly enjoy it.
But here is the thing: feedback is a gift. An ugly, uncomfortable, slightly painful gift. Like a sweater from your grandmother that doesn’t quite fit.
Nevertheless, it’s still a gift. Someone cared enough to wrap it up and hand it to you.
Therefore, here is your permission slip. Give feedback with kindness. Receive it with grace. And for heaven’s sake, give it before the disaster strikes.
Because between you and me, most disasters are preventable. Most crises are avoidable. Most failures could have been stopped with one honest conversation.
So stop waiting. Stop avoiding. Stop hoping it gets better on its own.
Give the feedback. Save the disaster. And sleep better knowing you spoke up.
The Bottom Line (Spoiler: It Gets Easier)
Ultimately, feedback becomes easier with practice.
The giver learns to be direct but kind. The receiver learns to listen without crying. Both sides learn that feedback is not personal—it’s professional.
So next time that calendar alert appears, take a breath. Prepare yourself. Remember that growth comes from discomfort.
And if you still hate it? Join the club. Nobody actually likes feedback.
But we all need it.
By Cosette Awad
Stay Connected:
Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/executivewomen_/
Connect on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/executive-women/
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ExecutiveWomen/
Read more articles: https://executive-women.global/so-you-thought-seo-was-hard-welcome-to-aeo-where-ai-decides-if-you-exist-by-cosette-awad/
